About Partners Contact Client Portal
LinkedIn Twitter
Services Industries Insights & Events Careers & Culture

Services

RubinBrown specializes in providing a comprehensive range of services to meet business and personal needs. Whether you require expert tax, strategic business consulting, audit services or more, RubinBrown's team of experienced professionals are here to support you.

View All Our Services
Assurance Services
Benefit Plan Audit Services Public Company Services SOC Examinations, IT Audit, & Third-Party Risk
Consulting Services
Business Process Improvement Services Business Restructuring & Bankruptcy Services Cyber Security Services Environmental, Social and Governance Services Independent ERP Selection Consultants Fraud & Forensics Healthcare SOC Examinations, IT Audit, & Third-Party Risk Information Technology Services Litigation Services Mergers & Acquisitions Services Risk & Internal Audit Services Valuation Services
Entrepreneurial Services
Outsourced Accounting & Advisory Services
Tax Services
Federal Tax Services Private Client Services Credits & Incentives Services State & Local Tax Services
RubinBrown Advisors RubinBrown Corporate Finance

Industries

At RubinBrown, we bring experience across a range of industries. Our experience enables our professionals to offer tailored solutions catering to the intricacies of each sector. Our professionals have years of focused engagement and skills, allowing them to navigate industry-specific challenges to benefit our clients.

View All Our Industries
Colleges & Universities Construction Gaming Healthcare Law Firms Life Sciences & Technology Manufacturing & Distribution Not-For-Profit Private Equity Public Sector Real Estate Transportation & Dealerships

Insights & Events

At RubinBrown, we provide valuable insights detailing emerging trends and industry-specific information. Our events, hosted virtually and in-person, keep you informed and connected to the topics and industries that matter most to you and your organization.

View All Insights & Events
Sep 9

RubinBrown’s Rural Health Webinar Series

Learn More & Register
Sep 24

RubinBrown’s Harnessing AI in Cybersecurity Seminar

Learn More & Register
Nov 13

RubinBrown’s Rural Health Webinar Series

Learn More & Register

Rock-Solid Documentation in Behavioral Health – Taking a Strategic Approach in Protecting Revenue

Learn More

Careers & Culture

At RubinBrown, we are inspired team members, working as one firm, living our core values, and Being Our Best for Others while delivering totally satisfied clients. We invite you to learn more about the Firm's culture, the Be Your Best for Others mentality, and explore the available opportunities at RubinBrown.

Discover Our Culture
Baker Tilly International Campus Recruiting Diversity & Inclusion Experienced Recruiting RubinBrown Charitable Foundation Join The Team
Back to Insights

Rock-Solid Documentation in Behavioral Health – Taking a Strategic Approach in Protecting Revenue

Contact Us

Rock-Solid Documentation in Behavioral Health – Taking a Strategic Approach in Protecting Revenue

Contact Us

Behavioral health practices are facing unprecedented challenges on multiple fronts.

Demand for mental health services has skyrocketed over the past few years, pushing providers to their capacity limits while major insurers have deployed automated systems that downcode higher-level office visits without human review.

This systematically decreases reimbursement for the complex evaluation and management services that psychiatrists and other providers deliver. Simultaneously, insurance companies often scrutinize longer psychotherapy sessions, flagging frequent use of 60-minute codes like 90837 and 90838 for audits and demanding medical necessity justification for the extended therapy time.

But here’s what many providers may not realize: strong, thorough documentation isn’t just helpful for compliance; it’s also a powerful tool to navigate auto-downcoding processes and payer reviews. It’s what strengthens appeals, safeguards revenue that’s been rightfully earned, and supports the ability to continue delivering high-quality, therapeutic care.

The Triple Threat: Clinical, Legal, and Financial Consequences

When it comes to healthcare, documentation serves three critical masters simultaneously.

  1. It drives clinical excellence by creating a roadmap of patient progress that enables informed treatment decisions and continuity of care.
  2. It functions as legal armor, providing concrete evidence of the care provided when facing audits, insurance disputes, or professional liability claims.
  3. It determines financial survival. Payors and regulatory agencies require specific documentation standards to justify every dollar they pay providers.

The reality is stark: inadequate documentation doesn't just mean delayed payments or administrative headaches. It can mean the difference between a thriving practice and a shuttered one.

What Makes Documentation Rock-Solid?

Start Strong with Comprehensive Initial Assessments

The initial assessment is not just checking boxes in a template. It's the foundation of medical necessity that supports future clinical and billing decisions. A robust assessment captures the complete clinical picture: presenting problems with specific symptom descriptions, comprehensive medical, family, psychiatric, and social histories, clear diagnostic reasoning, and treatment recommendations that directly address the patient’s needs.
The treatment plan must be more than a boilerplate document; it should outline specific interventions, realistic frequencies and timelines, and measurable outcomes that demonstrate the medical necessity from day one. It should also evolve with the patient’s progress and be kept up to date.

Progress Notes That Actually Prove Progress

Every session note should tell a story of therapeutic work and patient response. Generic templates that could apply to any patient and any therapy session are documentation disasters waiting to happen. Instead, providers should document the specific interventions used, how the patient responded, and measurable progress toward established goals, and outline any necessary modifications to the treatment plan.

As with any time-based code, the near-exact time spent in psychotherapy is non-negotiable. It must be accurate and realistic. Don’t rely on appointment times. Patients and clinicians can be late to start, and sessions can end early. Using structured formats, such as modality-specific templates and prompts for start and stop times, isn't just good practice; it supports efficiency in accurate documentation and can demonstrate what was performed is what was billed.

Documentation Excellence: Your Strategic Advantage

Master the Fundamentals

Excellence starts with timing and specificity. Services should be documented within 24-48 hours while details remain fresh, but providers should aim for same-day completion, including signatures, whenever possible. Establish policies and procedures around timely documentation and content requirements to enforce accountability. Replace vague language with precise descriptions of symptoms, interventions, and patient responses. Every record should be individualized to the patient and the encounter. While templates provide structure, copy-pasted or cloned documentation is a red flag for auditors and a liability in legal proceedings.

Build Sustainable Systems

The best documentation practices are those that can be maintained consistently under pressure. Develop streamlined workflows that capture essential information without overwhelming your schedule. An investment in structured templates that prompt critical elements while allowing for individualization goes a long way. Establish an auditing process that involves reviewing a sampling of high-risk services monthly to monitor accuracy and allows for timely provider feedback when errors are found.

The Bottom Line: Quality Documentation Isn’t Optional

Quality documentation isn't just about compliance; it's about building a sustainable, legally protected, and financially viable practice. When providers document with precision and purpose, they’re not just going through the motions; they’re creating a foundation for clinical excellence, legal protection, and financial stability. In an industry where the margin for error continues to shrink, documentation practices may be the single most important factor determining long-term success.

The path forward requires a systematic approach to identifying and addressing documentation gaps. A comprehensive chart audit reveals exactly where your records may be vulnerable to downcoding or recoupments, while targeted provider education equips your team with practical tools for consistent improvement. This foundation creates a sustainable culture of compliance and documentation excellence that protects practices while ensuring patients receive the quality care they deserve.


 

Published: 09/09/2025

Readers should not act upon information presented without individual professional consultation.

Any federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments): (i) is intended for your use only; (ii) is based on the accuracy and completeness of the facts you have provided us; and (iii) may not be relied upon to avoid penalties.

 

Contact Us:

Talk to Our Experts

Deb Kenney, CPC, CPMA, CRC, CPEDC Consultant deb.kenney@rubinbrown.com 810-853-6173

Be Your Best for Others at RubinBrown

At RubinBrown, our firm fosters a culture built upon five vision points, and are guided by our philosophy of Being Our Best for Others. Discover how you can be your best at RubinBrown today by visiting our Careers & Culture Overview for available opportunities and more.

Discover Our Culture

Join Our Mailing List

RubinBrown periodically sends breaking regulatory updates, technical summaries, industry-specific information and event (in-person and virtual) invitations through electronic newsletters.

Sign Up for Our Communications
1-800-678-3134 Certified Public Accountants & Business Consultants

Ranked a Top 50 Accounting Firm by Inside Public Accounting

Firm News Disclaimers Privacy Policy Client Payment © 2025 RubinBrown LLP
RubinBrown Executive Recruiting RubinBrown Advisors RubinBrown Corporate Finance